The Lifestreaming Verses Blogging Debate Revisited: Audio Discussion

Posted on 08/02/2009

In the most recent episode of The New Mediology (listen online or in iTunes), Nathan and I discussed the recent debate in social media circles that blogging is dead and that lifestreaming is the new thing to do. What prompted much of this debate was that at the end of June, one of the blogging world's top bloggers decided to abandon his blog in order to begin lifestreaming. The blogger, Steve Rubel, announced on his blog in a final post that he was leaving blogging to lifestream because "blogging feels old."

I've been reading Steve for several years now and have generally thought he was pretty well on track with things in social media, but I think he made a mistake this time. The mistake I believe he made is that he gave up ground as an influential voice in the world of social media in order to do something that does not continue to validate the voice he'd worked hard to develop.

With blogging, you have the chance to build a tribe by telling people what you think. If anyone is interested, they'll keep coming back to know more about what you think. With lifestreaming you don't tell people what you think. You're really just showing them the things you're thinking about. That's very different. Thought leaders offer perspective by telling you what they think. Everyone else just tells you the things that are on their mind, catch their eye, or just seem interesting. I believe Steve Rubel gave up a great seat at the thought leader table to go sit with everyone else.

If you're trying to establish a credible, authoritative voice on any topic, blogging is perhaps one of the best opportunities ever available to you to do so. You can do lifestreaming secondarily, but don't walk away from a chance to become a leader by telling people what you think.

-----

Unrelated Request: We need a new theme for the beginning and end of The New Mediology podcast. If you want to suggest a new show theme song at a site like Podsafe music, you own the rights for a song, or want to write an original song for the show, please let us know. We really, need a new one!

8/3/2009 3:32:04 PM
You make a good point Bill. As much as I respected Rubel's blog and the opinions that filled it, I'm not on board with him on this one. Dont get me wrong, I'm a fan of the lifestreaming format and adopted it about 9 months ago, organically. In my case, I took a premeditated break from blogging because it was a reflection of my life. I wanted to be online again but for different reasons, and I stumbled onto Tumblr. I find out nearly a year later that I am "lifestreaming" now. It was an easy transition because I was also not trying to build a "tribe" around my blog. In Rubel's case he has made great efforts, online and offline, to build his tribe. Then suddenly he's lifestreaming? He appears to jump to lifestreaming because it's what "the cool kids are doing" which I think happens more than we want to admit. I see way to many folks, notable and not, making dramatic shifts in how they communicate online based on what tools and/or formats are "hottest". I think this is evident on Twitter right now, I honestly think there are millions of people tweeting everyday and have no idea why.
8/3/2009 3:34:51 PM
Great thoughts here Steve. I agree...there probably are millions of people tweeting and have no idea why.
Jeremy Pinnix
8/3/2009 4:48:29 PM
I love that they are tweeting and don't care if they know why. At least they are communicating. There is a place for both formats. I will say, however, that after being a huge proponent of following/reading blogs I just took major action. I went from 384 feeds down to just 35 last night. I had taken a one month hiatus from reading blogs to see what really mattered. Not much it seems.
8/3/2009 6:13:09 PM
Bill - right on. I think it's a degeneration to go from blogging to "lifestreaming." In my old psychology schooling that was called "stream of consciousness" and we expected any garbage to just fall out of someone's brain. Noone I know has a stream of consciousness brilliant enough that I want to know every detail. I want content that has been thought out, researched, and leads to a suggested plan of action. "Lifestreaming?" - I'll just watch my 2-yr-old granddaughter and enjoy it for what it is.
8/3/2009 9:23:07 PM
Jeremy - Wow! That's a big reduction. I cut a lot of my feeds recently as well. Dan, I agree. The thinking things out and telling me what came from that process is one of the things I appreciate most from blogs.
8/6/2009 2:30:40 AM
I'd love to hear you talk more about this. I'm currently blogging and tweeting, as well as writing newsletters and publishing books. But I'm struggling with the decision of what to say where. I've linked my blogs to twitter, so my tweets (like yours) are often blog teasers. Then usually if I want to share a quick link or empowering quote, I also tweet about that. Do you have a system that you follow in your head?
8/6/2009 4:21:20 AM
Thanks Ann. Did you listen to the podcast already? I went a little bit more in depth on the topic there. You can hear it over at http://thenewmediology.com. As for a personal system, I try to make sure I'm balancing content and conversation with my Tweets and try to make sure I don't use it too much for purely promotional reasons. I have purposefully not linked to new blog posts I wrote because I didn't feel like I'd really done much other non-promo type of tweeting in the previous few days. When I'm really active in Twitter I don't worry about it, but when I'm less active, I pay a lot closer attention to that. Good question.
There are no trackbacks for this post.

Leave a Comment




 Security code

Subscribe via Email

Blog Roll

Categories

, 15 Megs of fame Alison Groves angel summoner and bmx bandit Anthology Creative Apple Atkinson PR Atkinson PR Nashville banner ads Barcamp Nashville batman dog Bible sniffer blog blogging blogs Bob Ross boot camp branding Burson-Marsteller business business blogging categories of web 2.0 celebrity CentreSource Mixer Chilis Foursquare Commentary content Content is the new promotion strategy crazy hail storm Del.icio.us digg digital marketing Digital Nashville double rainbow Double rainbow guy email embrace life psa employee celebrity Engage entrepreneur entrepreneurship facebook Facebook app iPad Facebook for Dummies Facebook in real life Facebook Nashville flood Farmville FeedBurner Firefly Logic Geek Social Firefox Flickr Flip Video for Forget the big fish Fortune 100 Foursquare Foxtrot double rainbow FreeConferenceCall.com funny ice cream server Gap Foursquare Geek Breakfast Nashville Gmail gobbledygook Google Google Adwords Google Analytics Google calendar Google docs Google Keyword Tool Google maps Google reader Google real-time search Gowalla Groundswell Groundswell ladder Groundswell updated history of social media Hubspot Hulu iGoogle Improv Everywhere Indian pole acrobat Internet stats interviews iPad iPad Facebook iPad social media iPad Twitter iPad Twitter app iPad Wired app iPhone iPod iPod Nano iStrategy conference Joe Penna language of smart LinkedIn location based social networking Mafia Wars Mark Vidler marketing Marketing Over Coffee meatball sundae media micro conference Micro Persuasion Microsoft Explorer mitch joel monitoring mossy creek custom music industry mysliceofpi MySpace mystery guitar man Nashcoctail Nashville Nashville flood Nashville flood recovery Nashville flooding Nashville PR Nashville recovery Nashville social media conference Nathan Moore New Fangled Web Factory new media new media marketing Ning NPR iPad app OK Go online video Outreach Magazine parkour Paul Schatzin penn olson personal Picnik Places Podcamp Podcamp Nashville podcast podcasting podcasts pole acrobatics pomplamoose POST method Promoted Tweets public relations radio advertising rainbow guy ray carman Ray Sadler real-time search remarkable ice cream server Remi Gaillard reporter hammer car rhett and link Rich K and the Allnighters Robert Scoble RSS Scot Justice search engine optimization search terms second life seo conference Nashville Seth Godin Simon Sinek Smells Like Rockin' Robin Smells Like Teen Spirit social social media social media batting practice Social Media budgets social media celebrity Social Media Club Nashville social media ethics social media events Nashville Social Media Examiner social media for business social media haiku social media in business social media in disaster social media jobs social media marketing social media measurement social media meetup Nashville social media mindset social media monitoring social media Nashville social media Nashville flood social media philosophy social media poop social media PR social media stats social networking social phone social search state of the Internet stats strategy successful blogging Super Mario Brothers violinist tags team approach to Twitter tech review technology stats teleseminar text message The New Mediology The New Rules of Marketing and PR the office parkour The State of Inbound Marketing tips Toyota Toyota funny commercial Toyota Sienna commercial Toyota swagger wagon Traditional media transparency turkish ice cream server twitter Twitter clicks Twitter for Dummies Twitter Nashville flood Twitter Promoted Tweets Twitter real time search Twitter search Twitter team approach underrated social media tools unicorn after wisdom teeth valuable vanilla ice social media Video video blog video conferencing Video of the week videos virtual cfo web 2.0 web 2.0 design web 2.0 marketing web applications web design web stats web trends widgets Wii Fit Wii Fit Parody Wikipedia word of mouth marketing Wordcamp Nashville Wordpress YouTube

Archives

  1. September 2010  (1)
  2. August 2010  (12)
  3. July 2010  (11)
  4. June 2010  (13)
  5. May 2010  (13)
  6. April 2010  (14)
  7. March 2010  (12)
  8. February 2010  (14)
  9. January 2010  (13)
  10. December 2009  (8)
  11. November 2009  (12)
  12. October 2009  (12)
  13. September 2009  (12)
  14. August 2009  (14)
  15. July 2009  (13)
  16. June 2009  (12)
  17. May 2009  (11)
  18. April 2009  (13)
  19. March 2009  (13)
  20. February 2009  (11)
  21. January 2009  (13)
  22. December 2008  (10)
  23. November 2008  (13)
  24. October 2008  (16)
  25. September 2008  (13)
  26. August 2008  (14)
  27. July 2008  (16)
  28. June 2008  (14)
  29. May 2008  (13)
  30. April 2008  (19)
  31. March 2008  (20)
  32. February 2008  (19)
  33. January 2008  (19)
  34. December 2007  (13)
  35. November 2007  (17)
  36. October 2007  (17)
  37. September 2007  (13)
  38. August 2007  (13)
  39. July 2007  (11)
  40. June 2007  (11)
  41. May 2007  (12)
  42. April 2007  (13)
  43. March 2007  (16)
  44. February 2007  (14)
  45. January 2007  (22)
  46. December 2006  (14)
  47. November 2006  (18)
  48. October 2006  (18)
  49. September 2006  (18)
  50. August 2006  (19)
  51. July 2006  (16)
  52. June 2006  (19)

© 2010 MicroExplosion Media - All rights reserved

Powered by NetEffect Services